How Pep the dog was sentenced to life in prison after being 'framed' for killing the Pennsylvania go

One mean mutt: Pep, the dog who was sentenced to life in prison in 1924 for killing Pennsylvania governor's cat

  • Pep the Black Labrador accused of killing cat belonging to the wife of Pennsylvania governor Gifford Pinchot

65

View
comments

He was known as the Pennsylvania cat-murderer, a vicious hound sentenced to life imprisonment at Eastern State Penitentiary for the grisly killing of the governor's moggie.

In his prison mugshot from 1924, he is seen with ears drooping backwards, an identification number hanging form around his neck looking decisively guilty.

According to newspapers stories at the time, Pep the Black Labrador attacked and killed a cat belonging to the wife of Pennsylvania's then governor Gifford Pinchot.

Falsely accused: Pep 'The Cat-Murdering Dog' in his prison mugshot after being admitted to Eastern State Penitentiary

Falsely accused: Pep 'The Cat-Murdering Dog' in his prison mugshot after being admitted to Eastern State Penitentiary

Showing absolutely no remorse for his despicable crimes, Pep was sent down for life with no chance of parole.

RELATED ARTICLES

Share this article

Share

But he was framed. Pep was actually entirely innocent, and his actual offence was nothing more serious than chewing the cushions of the sofa on the governor's front porch.

Owner: Pep had been a gift to Pennsylvania Governor Gifford Pinchot

Owner: Pep had been a gift to Pennsylvania Governor Gifford Pinchot

The account of him killing the cat was entirely fictitious, made up by a newspaper reporter taking a touch more than his fair share of journalistic licence.

The editor loved the story as it was frequently reprinted bearing the mugshot picture.

Governor Pinchot's son would later recall how his father was inundated with 'absolutely thousands of letters' about Pep and his prison sentence.

Of course the real story is far less exciting. Pep was originally a gift to Pennsylvania Governor  from the nephew of his wife Cornelia Bryce Pinchot.

One of her relatives relative was a breeder of Labrador Retrievers.

He became a much-loved part of the household at the start of Pinchot's first term as governor which lasted between 1923 and 1927.

But in early 1924 he began to develop a bad of chewing on the cushions of the front porch sofa.

Pinchot decided that the unruly dog had to go and a trip to a penitentiary in Maine had given him the perfect solution.

Pep was sent to Eastern State Penitentiary, but not as a prisoner.

On his visit to Maine, Governor Pinochet had seen dogs being used as therapy to help inmates rehabilitation, and thought Pep could be the perfect candidate.

So the naughty dog was packed off to prison as a pet where he became a favourite among the inmates.

Lock up: Pep became a firm favourite with inmates at Eastern State Penitentiary

Lock up: Pep became a firm favourite with inmates at Eastern State Penitentiary

In reality Pep was sent to the penitentiary as a pet for the prisoners after he developed a habit of chewing the governor's cushions

In reality Pep was sent to the penitentiary as a pet for the prisoners after he developed a habit of chewing the governor's cushions

In 1929 when the new Graterford prison was constructed about 50 miles away Pep would travel back and fourth with the prison work crew.

He eventually died of natural causes and is buried on the prison grounds.

The account of how Pep was framed is found in papers of the Governor Pinchot's son at the family home in Milford, Pennsylvania about 130 miles northeast of Philadelphia.

ncG1vNJzZmivp6x7pa3IpbCmmZmhe6S7ja6iaKaVrMBwrdGtoJyklWJ%2FdH6UbmpxZ3ikxG6cxKlknaeXYsCmutOepZydlGK5qrLEZqeroaOku26y0ZqknpxdoLatuMinnmaIlaO7tMXLr5inoZFitLDCxKulqKqjYq%2BmuM6vnJ1lk5bBb7TTpqM%3D